Members-only rates
3.4 / 5 Good

Commodore Resort

Commodore Resort
Commodore Resort – Put-in-Bay, OH
Commodore Resort – Put-in-Bay, OH
Check in 5:00 PM
Check out 11:00 AM

About Commodore Resort

Comfortable Accommodations Commodore Resort in Put-in-Bay offers adults-only rooms with air-conditioning, private bathrooms, and free WiFi. Each room includes a refrigerator, microwave, TV, and free toiletries. Leisure Facilities Guests can relax on the sun terrace, enjoy the seasonal outdoor swimming pool, and unwind in the hot tub. The property features a lounge, pool bar, and outdoor seating area. Dining Options The on-site restaurant serves pizza, complemented by a bar offering a variety of beverages. Live music enhances the dining experience. Location and Attractions Perry s Cave is a 13-minute walk away, and Toledo Express Airport is 70 mi from the hotel.

Amenities

  • 24-hour front desk
  • Meeting space
  • On-site dining
  • Bar / lounge
  • Express check-in / check-out
  • Luggage storage
  • Pool
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Smoke-free property
  • Elevator

Reviews

3.4 / 5
Good 531 reviews
  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    The rooms were awful terrible guest in other rooms people blasting music late hours you wake up with trash all over the ground outside people working there are rude, the property is disgusting had mold in our bathroom dust and dirt on walls spider webs wasn’t a fun place.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Don’t stay here lol. Extremely dirty

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    Room was absolutely disgusting. Shower and bathroom were nasty. I’d never stay there again. Room service never came and they wouldn’t give us new towels

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    This will be our last time staying here. The front desk staff was not very friendly. The room had a very damp feeling to it. Nothing we hung up every dried. Something outside our window dripped constantly our entire stay.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    The pool was great!

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    The bathroom door hit the toilet when you opened and closed the door. The toilet seat was loose The bathroom sink was plugged up and disgusting difficult to get clean linen's the staff were not friendly at all the pool opened late and closed early and the bars around the pool also closed early not even sure if they both were open we had two rooms reserved. They were supposed to be next to each other. however, they weren’t the interior and the exterior of the hotel were filthy

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    We enjoyed our stay. It was a bit loud some days. The room was sparse but we had cats with us, so I understand the minimalist due to animals. The bed & pillows could use an upgrade. Staff were great from check in to check out. Great pool & bars. We will definitely be returning. Great location. Love the all adults only !! Thank you.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    I was pleasantly surprised in how clean the room was, staff were nice

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    We booked this room as it was the only available room in short notice. After reading the other reviews we were genuinely worried. However, the hotel exceeded expectations. Our room was generally clean. There was some dust on the bed frame, the cleaning crew missed a flossing pic, and there was a black hair on the bed. This certainly isn’t a luxury hotel by any means, but was adequate for our weekend stay. There is the pool bar, and several other bars just outside. If you’re going to be partying and up late then it’s fine, otherwise bring some ear plugs. Mattresses aren’t good for back pain. Location is great if you’re looking to be in the restaurant /bar area. I really didn’t like that the entrance is in an alley as there are huge trash dumpsters outside that stink. You smell it every time you are in and out. Super weird setup with a subway stuffed into the lobby. Strong food smell in the lobby. The hallways smell strongly of cleaner. Overall the hotel was fine.

  • Engine customer Aug 2026

    It’s was ok clean room view was horrible

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Great place

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Location

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Pool bar was was a good time cold ac in the room overall would likely come back

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Liked the location and the golf cart rental was great!

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Beds are wrapped in plastic, the AC sounded like a machine gun going off all night long, floor was so dirty our feet were black from being barefoot. When asked office staff to send maintenance up to look at AC, they ignored the request.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    The "resort" is located right in the heart of all the action, we could walk to most nearby attractions/shopping/food. Our room which was labeled as "exterior - smoking" meant that outside the door was a nice picnic table and wicker chairs to sit on while enjoying the outdoors and having a cigarette. I was really disappointed in how dirty the room was for the amount we paid. I could not walk through the room after my shower without the bottom of my feet turning black from the filth. I am in no way a snob when it comes to hotels, and typically believe you get what you pay for, however this room was filthy and for the amount we paid, I would have expected them to mop in between each guest. Clearly the floors hadn't been cleaned in a long time. I also discovered a dental flosser on the floor from one of the previous guests and items left in the fridge from previous guests.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Clean nice room

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    At some point, it stops being an excuse and starts being terrible customer service. I was really looking forward to my first trip to PIB, but after this experience I’ll be staying somewhere else when I reschedule. God awful customer service, unprofessional management.

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    Perfect location

  • Engine customer Jul 2026

    The pool party

Frequently asked questions about Commodore Resort

Does Commodore Resort have free Wi-Fi?
Yes, Commodore Resort offers free Wi-Fi for all guests.
Does Commodore Resort offer parking?
Yes, Commodore Resort offers free parking on-site.
Does Commodore Resort have meeting spaces, conference centers, or conference rooms?
Yes. Commodore Resort offers meeting spaces for business and group use. Banquet and reception facilities are also available.
Does Commodore Resort have a fitness center?
Commodore Resort does not list an on-site fitness center. Some properties partner with nearby gyms — check directly with the hotel.
Where is Commodore Resort located, and how walkable is the area?
Commodore Resort is located at 272 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH OH 43456. With a Walk Score of 43, the area is rated Car-Dependent. A car or rideshare is recommended for most trips in this area.

Why no public rates?

Hotel partners contractually require business-email verification before showing the negotiated B2B rate. Hotel partners offer Engine exclusive business-traveler rates that aren't available to the public.

100% free and without commitment. Leave anytime.

Unlock exclusive rates